Frosthaven vs Gloomhaven
Updated
Both are Isaac Childres campaigns published by Cephalofair. Frosthaven does not require Gloomhaven. The shop copy says Frosthaven characters and items can cross over.
What I re-checked
Editorial decision: choose Jaws of the Lion for its built-in tutorial, learn-to-play guide and play-surface books. Choose Frosthaven if seasonal outpost construction appeals to your group. An unfinished Gloomhaven campaign you already own may be the practical first choice.
Gloomhaven second edition revises mercenary classes, items and scenarios, adds new narrative and events, and uses faction-based reputation. It is a separate purchase decision from continuing a first-edition campaign; do not assume every item number or class rule is interchangeable.
| Product | Published distinction | Editorial fit |
|---|---|---|
| Frosthaven | Standalone 138-scenario campaign, seasons and player-built outpost | Groups wanting substantial between-scenario progression |
| Gloomhaven first edition | Original campaign; some expansions explicitly require this edition | Continue an owned campaign rather than replacing it automatically |
| Gloomhaven second edition | Redesigned classes/items/scenarios and faction reputation | Compare the revised core game, not merely a printing correction |
| Jaws of the Lion | Standalone prequel, four mercenaries, tutorial and play-surface books | A structured teaching entry point |
Questions
Should I buy Frosthaven or Gloomhaven first?
Our recommendation is Jaws of the Lion for its explicit teaching support, Frosthaven for outpost progression, or your existing unfinished Gloomhaven campaign to avoid another large purchase. Gloomhaven second edition deserves its own revised-game comparison, not a claim that Frosthaven is automatically the newest release.
Related guides
Sources
- Cephalofair products.json — Frosthaven, Jaws of the Lion and edition-specific expansion descriptions, checked 2026-10-18.
- Asmodee Gloomhaven second edition — Distributor's primary edition description: redesigned classes, items and scenarios, new narrative and faction reputation. Checked 2026-10-18.
- Steam app 2347080 — US price, 2026-10-18.